• Your Cart is Empty

The Peanut Butter Cups That Will Put Your No Candy Diet To Shame

The Peanut Butter Cups That Will Put Your No Candy Diet To Shame

When I was 8 years old, I developed a candy drawer. I wish it were healthy candy, but alas, it wasn’t.

It was mostly Reese’s peanut butter cups (God I loved those) hard candy (to the chagrin of my dentist) and candy bars.

Can you blame me?

There’s no shame in loving candy.

The candy drawer was not a guilty-pleasure drawer; it was more like a handy tool for little me. Any time I got candy from a special event  -like a birthday party pinata- I would save it until I got home to stash it in my drawer like a hidden treasure. 

The hiding place was essential for 2 reasons.

Reason number 1: I had a good number of siblings, none of which I wanted to be fondling or munching on my hard-earned goodies (those rascals!) And reason number 2, I needed a candy trove within reach at all times so when my taste buds screamed for a sweet surprise I was fully prepared and ready to take action. Like the Boy Scouts, but with candy.

Now, many years later, I still have a hidden candy drawer. But for a slightly different reason. 

Having healthy candy alternatives at hand makes it easier to stay on track with your goals.

Yes, the contents of my drawers have changed, but not my love for candy. I’m happy to report my current dentist thoroughly approves of this drawer.

The truth is, in the past if I didn’t hide any and all candy out of sight and out of reach it would eventually find its way into my mouth and go straight to that one part of my waistline I struggle with sometimes. It also may have also increased my dentist visits.

I had to learn how to stop sugar cravings, or at least manage them for the sake of my dental plan,

The good thing is, I’ve learned to respect my health and make choices that better support my goals and journey. I want to live to a hundred! And healthy candy seems like a good way to get there. 

Sounds good? 

This Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Inspired alternative will delight your taste buds, keep you on track with your health goals and make 8-year old you very, very happy - they’re also really good for Halloween.

(Meet you at our 101 birthday parties, I’ll be the one yapping about healthy candy and how they spared me from prosthetic teeth ;) )

A Healthy Candy Alternative For Candy Lovers

My favorite thing about this recipe is that it’s a delicious candy alternative that’s not only healthy, yummy, and fun, but is also packed with superfood diet bonuses.

 A treat you can eat anytime and anywhere!

Yessiree, these are the real deal. And if there’s anything better than chocolate with peanut butter, it’s chocolate with peanut butter PLUS a ton of health benefits, all mixed together in delectable goodness.

It totally counts as candy, flavor-wise, but it’s enriched with some superfoods that you can brag about when people compliment your super-duper-yummy peanut butter cups.

What’s Super About Our Superfood Peanut Butter Cups?

Our healthy candy alternative, that I hereby dub “Superfood Peanut Butter Cups” are easy to make with just four ingredients, tasty enough to satisfy your sweet tooth while still healthy enough to keep you from negative self-talk and misplaced guilt.

They are full of wholesome ingredients from our seasonal-favorite Gold, Chocolate. 

The Superfood Ingredients in Gold, Chocolate:

(you only taste the chocolate!)

  • Cocoa Powder
  • Turmeric
  • Lemon Balm
  • Turkey Tail Mushroom Extract
  • Red Reishi Mushroom Extract
  • Coconut Milk Powder
  • Acacia Fiber (prebiotic)
  • Ceylon Cinnamon Powder
  • Ginger 
  • Black Pepper
  • Organic Vanilla 
  • Coconut Sugar
  • Monk Fruit

This is why they qualify as “healthy candy,” but because of the powerful cocoa flavor, vanilla, cinnamon, coconut sugar, and monk fruit, you can’t really taste the other remarkable superfoods in the blend. You get the benefits of turmeric and Reishi mushroom powder without tasting them!

If you want to know why it’s good for you (and I recommend that you do #braggingrights) read on, if not skip down to the recipe below.


4 Perks of Gold, Chocolate - Our Star Ingredient.

#1 May Boost Feel-Good Brain Chemicals

There are some really cool science-backed effects of chocolate on the brain, and some research suggests that the cocoa flavonoids in dark chocolate (70% cocoa or more) could enhance your mood by boosting serotonin and anandamide.

These neurotransmitters, among other functions, may make you feel “happier.” Interestingly, anandamide was named after the Sanskrit word “Ananda” which means bliss or joy.

Don’t know about you, but that sounds pretty good to me. Healthy candy (and chocolate) FTW! 

#2 Low Sugar Could Make Your Dentist Happy

With only one gram of sugar, it’s bound to be healthier than your regular go-to candy bar. Dentists like it when you eat less sugar and brush your teeth (I have hands-on experience)

And so does your body! 

While other chocolate products on the market are overflowing with processed sugars and sweeteners, this one is not. Sweetened with coconut sugar and monk fruit it could even be diabetic-friendly!

#3 Might Be a Good Source of Antioxidants 

Chocolate antioxidants could make your skin look better and may even support the immune system.  Our Gold, Chocolate blend contains one of the highest-ranking antioxidant sources on the planet, raw cacao bean. It has reportedly more antioxidants than kale, blueberries and goji berries.

Now that’s not to say all chocolate can do that, as high sugar and processing content could undermine the antioxidant value of the fruit, but it could explain why it helps your body fight aging and oxidation. See why healthy candy may be better than regular candy?

#4 Could Give You More Energy

Leveraging the anti-stress properties of adaptogen herbs and mushrooms like Reishi, Turkey Tail Mushroom, and the anti-inflammatory potential of turmeric, this healthy chocolate alternative could support better rest and energy management. It could even be an alternative for your daily cup of coffee.

By now, you’re probably thinking - you had me at healthy candy. So let’s get cooking!

Superfood Peanut Butter Cups with Healthy Chocolate

This healthy candy alternative is so easy to make you won’t believe how quickly you put them together, even if your previous forays into the kitchen ended in mild batter explosions. 


  • 1 cup organic virgin coconut oil
  • 1/2 cup Gold, Chocolate 
  • 2 tsp real vanilla extract
  • 1/4 cup raw peanut or almond butter


  1. Mix the first 3 ingredients in a saucepan over low heat.
  2. Pour 1 tbsp of mixture in the bottom of each muffin tin or cupcake liner.
  3. Freeze for 20 minutes.
  4. Top each with 1 tsp raw peanut butter or almond butter.
  5. Pour the remaining chocolate sauce over the top of each peanut butter cup.
  6. Freeze until ready to eat. Enjoy!

Bottom Line: Take The “Die” Out Of Dieting

Keeping a healthy candy alternative on hand, like these bad boys over here, for when cravings come is a great way to make sure you’re not affecting your health for instant-gratification that may have long term harmful effects on your body (and I’m not talking about looks) as excess sugar has been linked with chronic conditions. 

It also changes your mindset from “dieting” and deprivation, to fun and fulfilled. It’s a whole lot easier to live like that. Indulge in things that you love with a healthy twist, that way you both eat the cake and bake it -without sacrificing taste or pleasure. Something as simple as a healthy sugar substitute helps.

Do you have any tips on how to stop sugar cravings or give into unhealthy munchies? We’d love to know. 

If you try out these Superfood Peanut Butter Cups share your story and tag us in your masterpiece’s pic.

We're in this together.

EASIER THAN YOU THINK! Enjoy the full benefits of an organic juicing lifestyle without all the shopping, chopping, and clean-up. Our premium superfood blends deliver powerful nutrition with perfect flavor - every time.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in News

Celebrating Sustainability and Mindfulness on International Yoga Day
Celebrating Sustainability and Mindfulness on International Yoga Day

International Yoga Day is June 21st! We’re thrilled to announce our partnership with Manduka, a company created by yogis (and loved by teachers worldwide) to provide yoga equipment designed by mindful mentors. 

Read More

Ultimate 2021 Gift Guide for the Active Dad
Ultimate 2021 Gift Guide for the Active Dad

This is your Ultimate 2021 Gift Guide for the Active Dad! Let’s go beyond another pair of sneakers or the soon-to-be-abandoned “gadget of the year". This time we’re serving up the gifts that empower dad to be his best self, everyday. 


Read More

6 Ways To Feel and Look Your Best This Summer
6 Ways To Feel and Look Your Best This Summer

What’s the difference between a few warm months and your healthiest, most vibrant Summer yet? A handful of simple choices you can make on a daily basis.

Read More